請用此 Handle URI 來引用此文件:
http://tdr.lib.ntu.edu.tw/jspui/handle/123456789/93067
標題: | 非政治議題、政治議題與事實查核:臺灣事實查核成效之探討 Non-Political Issue, Political Issue and Fact-Checking : An Examination of the Effectiveness of Fact-Checking in Taiwan |
作者: | 魏志展 Jhih-Jhan Wei |
指導教授: | 張佑宗 Yu-tzung Chang |
關鍵字: | 假新聞,事實查核,雙重歷程理論,動機推論,政黨認同,政府信任度, Fake news,Fact-checking,Dual-Processing Theory,Motivated Reasoning,Party identification,Trust in government, |
出版年 : | 2024 |
學位: | 碩士 |
摘要: | 現代網路與社群媒體的興盛,助長了假新聞廣傳的勢頭,臺灣在這股浪潮中,更是受害國家當中的佼佼者。假新聞於民主社會內部的傳遞,讓民眾對民主體制的信任逐漸崩潰,而為了防範事態愈發嚴重,事實查核組織出現於各國民間,以應對日漸失控的假新聞。不過,事實查核機制的運作,似乎仍難以阻擋假新聞的衝擊,其中的緣故,彷彿與大眾如何看待事實查核機制脫離不了關聯。本研究以Dual-Processing Theory作為理論框架,主張不同議題的假新聞,會觸發個人不同的推論模式,使得不同議題假新聞的查核成效有所差異。本研究以臺灣為探討案例,分析事實查核機制分別於非政治議題與政治議題假新聞的效果,其中以生活議題假新聞代表非政治議題,民進黨議題、 國民黨議題假新聞代表政治議題,依三組議題討論事實查核機制的運作。
本研究發現,事實查核機制於應對生活議題和國民黨議題的假新聞,能夠盡其所長,有效引導個人去拒絕假新聞的論述,只是針對國民黨議題的假新聞,需要民眾有意願去閱讀完整查核資訊才能發揮功能。然而,應對民進黨議題的假新聞,事實查核機制則毫無用武之地。由此,本研究推論臺灣民眾大多能理性找出資訊正確與否,唯獨面對民進黨議題的假新聞時,僅會使用個人的直覺來對假新聞正確性作出判斷。本研究推斷,該現象是基於現行政治環境大量流傳不利政府與執政黨形象的假新聞,致使臺灣民眾在該類型假新聞的耳濡目染下,對政府與執政黨的信任日益降低,應對該類型假新聞的事實查核因而難以大展身手,配合現行假新聞大多會損及政府信任度的特質來看,臺灣事實查核組織在釐清政府和執政黨形象的查核工作上,將會面臨較大的挑戰。 The rise of modern Internet and social media platforms has fueled the spread of fake news, with Taiwan emerging as one of the most affected nations in this wave. The circulation of fake news within democratic societies is eroding public trust in democratic institutions. To combat the worsening situation, fact-checking organizations have emerged worldwide to address the growing issue of uncontrolled fake news. However, the effectiveness of fact-checking mechanisms seems insufficient to halt the impact of fake news, and the reason for this seems to be closely related to how the public perceives fact-checking mechanisms. This study employs the Dual-Processing Theory as theoretical framework, and suggests that fake news on different topics triggers distinct reasoning modes in individuals, affecting the efficiency of fact-checking efforts across various issues. Focusing on Taiwan, this research analyzes the effectiveness of fact-checking mechanisms on non-political and political fake news, with life issues representing as non-political topics, and fake news related to the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) and the Kuomintang (KMT) as political topics. The findings indicate that fact-checking mechanisms effectively guide individuals to reject false narratives concerning life issues and KMT-related fake news. Although, for fake news specific to KMT issues, their effectiveness hinges on the public's willingness to thoroughly read the fact-checking information. However, when dealing with DPP-related fake news, fact-checking efforts prove ineffective. This suggests that Taiwanese people are generally capable of discerning the accuracy of information through reasoning, except when facing DPP-related fake news, where they tend to rely on intuition. The study infers that this phenomenon results from the extensive circulation of fake news detrimental to the government and ruling party's image, leading to decreased trust among Taiwanese people towards these entities. Consequently, fact-checking against such fake news faces significant predicament. Given that most current fake news tends to undermine government credibility, Taiwanese fact-checking organizations will face greater challenges in their efforts to clarify the image of the government and the ruling party through their fact-checking work. |
URI: | http://tdr.lib.ntu.edu.tw/jspui/handle/123456789/93067 |
DOI: | 10.6342/NTU202401439 |
全文授權: | 同意授權(全球公開) |
顯示於系所單位: | 政治學系 |
文件中的檔案:
檔案 | 大小 | 格式 | |
---|---|---|---|
ntu-112-2.pdf | 14.7 MB | Adobe PDF | 檢視/開啟 |
系統中的文件,除了特別指名其著作權條款之外,均受到著作權保護,並且保留所有的權利。