Skip navigation

DSpace

機構典藏 DSpace 系統致力於保存各式數位資料(如:文字、圖片、PDF)並使其易於取用。

點此認識 DSpace
DSpace logo
English
中文
  • 瀏覽論文
    • 校院系所
    • 出版年
    • 作者
    • 標題
    • 關鍵字
    • 指導教授
  • 搜尋 TDR
  • 授權 Q&A
    • 我的頁面
    • 接受 E-mail 通知
    • 編輯個人資料
  1. NTU Theses and Dissertations Repository
  2. 法律學院
  3. 科際整合法律學研究所
請用此 Handle URI 來引用此文件: http://tdr.lib.ntu.edu.tw/jspui/handle/123456789/104296
標題: 論終身監禁—從英美法的考察出發
A Study on Life Without Parole: Lessons from the Anglo-American Experience
作者: 施勇鴻
Yung-Hung Shih
指導教授: 謝煜偉
Yu-Wei Hsieh
關鍵字: 終身監禁; 無期徒刑; 假釋; 動態責任; 應報; 社會復歸
Life Without Parole; Life Sentence; Parole; Dynamic Responsibility; Retribution; Social Rehabilitation
出版年 : 2026
學位: 碩士
摘要: 憲法法庭113年憲判字第8號判決作成後,在野黨宣稱台灣已走向「實質廢死」,在此背景下,立法院各黨團與法務部陸續提出刑法修正草案,欲參考英美引入「終身監禁不得假釋」制度。然而,這樣的刑罰在英美究竟生成於什麼樣的社會脈絡?帶來了何等的政策後果?又能否通過規範上的檢驗?本文循著以上三個提問,首先考察英美二國自1970年代以降的刑事政策變遷,指出終身監禁實為多重力量交織下的產物:社會復歸理想逐漸崩解、公正應報路線隨之復興,加上新刑罰學帶來的廢棄物管理邏輯,共同促使當代刑事司法從包容走向排除。在此基礎上,本文分別從政策與規範兩個面向提出批判。政策面向上,本文指出不論是意在替代死刑或者強調犯罪預防,終身監禁都無法發揮預期的效果,並可能使刑罰控制網擴張、對監獄功能產生嚴重衝擊,同時掩蓋潛藏的社會問題。規範面向上,本文援引動態責任論,主張刑罰所施加的非難應該是動態且雙向的對話過程,行為人的罪責隨著時間與後續事態的發展可能產生變動,而假釋制度同時兼具重新檢視行為人責任的功能。準此,終身監禁永久剝奪假釋機會,使得持續變化的責任在漫長的刑罰執行過程中無從被重新評價,可能導致受刑人被迫承擔超過其應得的刑罰。
Following the Constitutional Court's Judgment No. 8 of 2024, opposition parties declared that Taiwan had effectively abolished the death penalty. Against this backdrop, party caucuses in the Legislative Yuan and the Ministry of Justice put forward a series of proposed amendments to the Criminal Code, seeking to introduce “life without parole” (LWOP) on the model of the United States and the United Kingdom. Out of what social context, however, did this penalty arise? What policy consequences has it produced? And can it be justified in normative terms? Taking up these three questions in turn, this thesis begins by tracing how criminal policy in these two jurisdictions shifted from the 1970s onward, and finds that LWOP emerged from several forces working at once: as the rehabilitative ideal fell apart, just deserts returned to prominence, and the new penology brought with it a logic of waste management—together pushing contemporary criminal justice from inclusion toward exclusion. On this basis, the thesis advances a critique from two perspectives, one of policy and one of normative theory. From the policy perspective, it argues that whether the aim is to replace the death penalty or to strengthen crime prevention, LWOP cannot deliver its anticipated effects. What it does instead is widen the net of penal control, hollow out the functions of the prison, and draw attention away from the social problems that lie beneath serious crime. From the normative perspective, the thesis draws on theories of dynamic responsibility to argue that the censure conveyed by punishment should be a dynamic and bilateral communicative process, that an offender's criminal responsibility may change with the passage of time and with subsequent developments, and that parole accordingly serves the further function of re-examining the offender's responsibility. Consequently, by permanently depriving prisoners of any opportunity for parole, LWOP leaves this continually changing responsibility without any means of reassessment over the long course of the sentence, which may force prisoners to bear punishment exceeding what they deserve.
URI: http://tdr.lib.ntu.edu.tw/jspui/handle/123456789/104296
DOI: 10.6342/NTU202604341
全文授權: 同意授權(全球公開)
電子全文公開日期: 2026-08-26
顯示於系所單位:科際整合法律學研究所

文件中的檔案:
檔案 大小格式 
ntu-114-2.pdf2.89 MBAdobe PDF檢視/開啟
顯示文件完整紀錄


系統中的文件,除了特別指名其著作權條款之外,均受到著作權保護,並且保留所有的權利。

社群連結
聯絡資訊
10617臺北市大安區羅斯福路四段1號
No.1 Sec.4, Roosevelt Rd., Taipei, Taiwan, R.O.C. 106
Tel: (02)33662353
Email: ntuetds@ntu.edu.tw
意見箱
相關連結
館藏目錄
國內圖書館整合查詢 MetaCat
臺大學術典藏 NTU Scholars
臺大圖書館數位典藏館
本站聲明
© NTU Library All Rights Reserved