Skip navigation

DSpace

機構典藏 DSpace 系統致力於保存各式數位資料(如:文字、圖片、PDF)並使其易於取用。

點此認識 DSpace
DSpace logo
English
中文
  • 瀏覽論文
    • 校院系所
    • 出版年
    • 作者
    • 標題
    • 關鍵字
    • 指導教授
  • 搜尋 TDR
  • 授權 Q&A
    • 我的頁面
    • 接受 E-mail 通知
    • 編輯個人資料
  1. NTU Theses and Dissertations Repository
  2. 進修推廣部
  3. 事業經營法務碩士在職學位學程
請用此 Handle URI 來引用此文件: http://tdr.lib.ntu.edu.tw/jspui/handle/123456789/104132
標題: 私部門賄賂罪立法影響評估-以汽車零售業為例
Legislative Impact Assessment on the Criminalization of Private Sector Bribery: The Case of the Automotive Retail Industry
作者: 王俊堯
Chung-Yao Wang
指導教授: 謝煜偉
Yu-Wei Hsieh
關鍵字: 私部門賄賂罪; 商業賄賂; 保護法益; 汽車零售業; 企業間交易; 終端消費交易
Private sector bribery; Commercial bribery; Protected legal interests; Automotive retail industry; Business-to-business (B2B); Business-to-consumer (B2C)
出版年 : 2026
學位: 碩士
摘要: 現代商業實務多元,針對私部門賄賂行為是否應予入罪化,以及其刑罰界線應如何劃定,為我國刑事立法面臨的重要課題。本研究聚焦於私部門賄賂罪的保護法益,探討學理上的「業主模式」、「競爭模式」與「業務執行公正性模式」,並以我國「汽車零售業」為實證檢視對象,檢驗抽象法理與具體產業的適性。
透過與產業實務的交互檢證,研究指出:若將汽車銷售人員私下收受外部廠商佣金並進行引薦的行為,涵攝於上述三大法益模式,均難以證立其具備發動國家刑罰權的實質法益侵害性。在未對雇主造成具體財產損害的前提下,強行將此類行為入罪,不僅構成對自由市場與私法自治的過度干預,更恐使國家刑罰權淪為企業主轉嫁內部管理成本的工具。
為建構具備實務合理性的規範界線,本研究建議可考慮導入「類型化區隔」,區分「企業間交易(Business-to-Business, B2B)」與「終端消費交易(Business-to-Consumer, B2C)」。企業間交易的利益輸送,因涉及代理問題且具備扭曲整體市場競爭的系統性風險,確實存有納入刑罰規範的探討空間;但終端消費交易因消費者保有最終締約自由,缺乏重大的法益侵害性,故應在立法上明確排除適用。
總結而言,面對終端消費市場立法政策應揚棄對刑罰的過度依賴,防弊重心應回歸企業法遵治理與勞動懲戒,並輔以現行民事損害賠償及《刑法》背信罪等財產犯罪作為最終防線。
最終,本研究期盼以汽車零售業的實務探討為借鏡,促使未來的刑事立法能充分審酌不同產業間的交易特性,進而建構更具實務合理性的規範體系。
Given the diversity of modern commercial practices, whether private sector bribery should be criminalized and how its penal boundaries should be delineated constitute crucial issues for criminal legislation. This study focuses on the protected legal interests of the offense of private sector bribery, exploring the theoretical frameworks of the "Owner Model," the "Competition Model," and the "Impartiality in Business Execution Model." Using the automobile retail industry as an empirical case study, it examines the applicability of these abstract legal theories to specific industry contexts.
Through cross-examination with industry practices, this research indicates that if the conduct of automobile salespersons privately accepting commissions from and making referrals to third-party vendors is subsumed under the aforementioned three models, it is difficult to establish a substantive infringement of legal interests sufficient to justify the invocation of state penal power. Criminalizing such conduct without concrete financial loss to the employer not only constitutes excessive interference with the free market and private law autonomy, but also risks reducing state penal power to a mere tool for business owners to externalize their internal management costs.
To construct practically reasonable normative boundaries, this study suggests introducing a categorical differentiation between Business-to-Business (B2B) and Business-to-Consumer (B2C) transactions. The illicit transfer of benefits in B2B transactions, due to inherent agency problems and the systemic risk of distorting overall market competition, indeed warrants consideration for criminal regulation. Conversely, in B2C transactions, because consumers retain the ultimate freedom of contract, there is a lack of significant infringement on legal interests; therefore, such transactions should be explicitly excluded from criminal applicability in legislation.
In conclusion, regarding the end-consumer market, legislative policy should abandon its over-reliance on criminal penalties. The focus of prevention should return to corporate compliance governance and labor disciplinary measures, supplemented by existing civil claims for damages and property crimes under the Criminal Code, such as the offense of breach of trust, as the ultimate line of defense.
Ultimately, this study hopes that the empirical analysis of the automobile retail industry will serve as a reference point, prompting future criminal legislation to fully consider the diverse transaction characteristics across different industries, thereby establishing a more practically sound normative framework.
URI: http://tdr.lib.ntu.edu.tw/jspui/handle/123456789/104132
DOI: 10.6342/NTU202602794
全文授權: 同意授權(全球公開)
電子全文公開日期: 2026-08-25
顯示於系所單位:事業經營法務碩士在職學位學程

文件中的檔案:
檔案 大小格式 
ntu-114-2.pdf2.16 MBAdobe PDF檢視/開啟
顯示文件完整紀錄


系統中的文件,除了特別指名其著作權條款之外,均受到著作權保護,並且保留所有的權利。

社群連結
聯絡資訊
10617臺北市大安區羅斯福路四段1號
No.1 Sec.4, Roosevelt Rd., Taipei, Taiwan, R.O.C. 106
Tel: (02)33662353
Email: ntuetds@ntu.edu.tw
意見箱
相關連結
館藏目錄
國內圖書館整合查詢 MetaCat
臺大學術典藏 NTU Scholars
臺大圖書館數位典藏館
本站聲明
© NTU Library All Rights Reserved