請用此 Handle URI 來引用此文件:
http://tdr.lib.ntu.edu.tw/jspui/handle/123456789/102374| 標題: | 論強制性精神醫療處遇——從對障礙觀點的反思出發 Reconsidering Mandatory Medical Treatment: A Critical Reflection on the Concept of Disability |
| 作者: | 曾亭瑄 Ting-Hsuan Tseng |
| 指導教授: | 謝煜偉 Yu-Wei Hsieh |
| 關鍵字: | 監護處分; 強制治療; 身心障礙者權利公約; 關懷倫理; 當事者研究 Custodial Protection; Compulsory Treatmen; CRPD; Ethics of Care; Tojisha-Kenkyu |
| 出版年 : | 2026 |
| 學位: | 碩士 |
| 摘要: | 近年來,社會上發生多起精神障礙者觸法事件引起大眾恐慌。在這樣的背景下,政府於2022年針對精神障礙者相關規範進行修正,其中包含精神衛生法下的強制治療和監護處分。此種針對精神障礙者之強制性精神醫療處遇由於涉及對特定群體人身自由之拘束,相關政策之實施向來飽受爭議。
另一方面,聯合國於2008年施行《身心障礙者權利公約》。公約採取了人權模式而非過往的醫療模式理解障礙,並依此對身心障礙相關規範提出新的規範要求。然而,人權模式於身心障礙相關規範,特別是強制精神醫療處遇制度方面所採取的見解與各國既有法制始終存在不小的分歧與爭議。 關於監護處分和精神衛生法下之強制治療的研究,過往多數文獻多著重於比較法上的分析和適用,較少從更上位的障礙觀點出發討論相關規範的適切性。基此,本文從如何看待障礙的角度切入,分析了醫療模式及人權模式形成背後的脈絡以及觀點各自所面臨之問題。隨後透過關懷倫理學上對於自主與依賴的分析和當事者研究核心精神的討論,重新檢視與確立障礙觀點內涵。最後,在釐清了何種障礙觀點適於作為思考的上位基礎後,以此為基礎回歸對我國現行規範之討論,對刑法之監護處分及精神衛生法之強制治療提出立法論及解釋論上之建議。 In recent years, crimes committed by people with mental illnesses have attracted widespread public concern. Against this backdrop, the government amended the law on compulsory psychiatric treatment for people with mental illnesses in 2022, including the compulsory medical treatment in the Mental Health Law and the custodial punishment in the Criminal Law. However, as these mandatory psychiatric treatment for people with mental illnesses involve the restraint of personal liberty of specific groups, the implementation of relevant policies has long been a subject of significant controversy. On the other hand, the United Nations implemented the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) in 2008. The Convention adopts the human rights model of disability rather than the medical model to understand disability, and sets forth new normative requirements for disability-related regulations. However, regarding disability-related regulations, particularly the compulsory psychiatric treatment system, there has consistently been significant divergence and controversy between the views of the human rights model and the existing legal systems of various countries. Regarding research on the custodial punishment and the compulsory medical treatment in the Mental Health Law, most previous research has emphasized the analysis and application of comparative law, while few have discussed the appropriateness of relevant regulations from a more foundational disability perspective. Therefore, this thesis approaches the issue by examining how disability is perceived, analyzing the contexts behind the formation of the medical model and the human rights model, as well as the challenges faced by each. Then, through the analysis of autonomy and dependency within the ethics of care and the discussion on Tojisha-Kenkyu, it re-examines and establishes the concept of the disability. Finally, after clarifying the most appropriate conception of disability as a foundational framework, this study returns to the discussion of Taiwan’s current regulations, proposing recommendations on de lege ferenda and de lege lata regarding the custodial punishment in the Criminal Law and the compulsory medical treatment in the Mental Health Law. |
| URI: | http://tdr.lib.ntu.edu.tw/jspui/handle/123456789/102374 |
| DOI: | 10.6342/NTU202601079 |
| 全文授權: | 同意授權(全球公開) |
| 電子全文公開日期: | 2026-06-17 |
| 顯示於系所單位: | 法律學系 |
文件中的檔案:
| 檔案 | 大小 | 格式 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| ntu-114-2.pdf | 3.04 MB | Adobe PDF | 檢視/開啟 |
系統中的文件,除了特別指名其著作權條款之外,均受到著作權保護,並且保留所有的權利。
